Fox Valley Gutters
Our Methodology

How We Grade
Gutter Pros

Every contractor in our directory receives an independent letter grade (A to D) based on five factors drawn from public data. We never accept payment to influence rankings, and no gutter company can buy a better score.

How It Works

1

We Collect Data

Google reviews, the insurance, bonding and certifications each business states on its own website, and business details — all from public sources.

2

We Score Five Factors

Each gutter company is evaluated across five weighted categories totaling 100 points.

3

We Assign a Grade

Points map to a letter grade from A (best) to D. Low scorers show as "Limited info". Updated as new reviews and records come in.

The Five Factors

Each factor is weighted to reflect what matters most when hiring a gutter contractor in northeast Wisconsin.

Customer Reviews 30 PTS

We use each contractor's Google rating and review count. But the star average isn't the whole story — review volume, recency, and how the contractor responds to complaints all factor in. A shop with 140 reviews averaging 4.6 scores higher than one with 5 perfect reviews from 2019.

Credentials & Insurance 25 PTS

Wisconsin does not license gutter contractors at the state level (a DSPS Dwelling Contractor credential applies only to work that needs a building permit on a one- or two-family home), so we look for general liability insurance, workers' comp, and bonding as listed on each contractor's own website. Business details come from each company’s own website and public profiles, collected on the date shown, and owners can correct their listing at any time by claiming it. Manufacturer certifications from leaf guard brands like LeafFilter, Gutter Helmet, and LeafGuard earn additional points.

Years of Experience 15 PTS

Longevity isn't everything — but a gutter company that has survived multiple Fox Valley winters, ice dam seasons, and spring downpours has proven it can run a durable operation. Newer shops aren't penalized, just scored more cautiously.

Profile Completeness 15 PTS

Phone number from the business's Google profile, functional website, clear service area, and published business hours. Gutter pros who make it easy to reach them and understand what they specialize in score higher than those with scattered or outdated information.

Specialization 15 PTS

Whether gutters and exterior water management are their core business, not a side service bolted onto a roofing outfit or a general handyman shop. Dedicated gutter specialists run seamless gutter machines on their own trucks, carry the right K-style and half-round profiles in 5" and 6", and know the difference between a micro-mesh screen and a reverse-curve leaf guard.

The Grade Scale

Points are totaled and mapped to a letter grade. Only A and B contractors are featured prominently in our directory.

A
Outstanding (85–100 pts)

Excellent reviews, credentials on its website, strong Fox Valley track record, dedicated gutter specialist.

B
Strong (70–84 pts)

Solid reputation, good credentials, and clear specialization. A safe pick for most Fox Valley homes.

C
Average (55–69 pts)

Decent but with limited information or mixed reviews. Worth getting a second quote from.

D
Below Average (40–54 pts)

Sparse profile, very few reviews, or credential gaps. Always get multiple quotes.

Limited info
Limited info (under 40 pts)

Not enough public data to form a judgment. Low scorers show as "Limited info".

The Fine Print

Can gutter companies pay to improve their grade?

No. Our grades are generated from public data and cannot be influenced by payment, advertising relationships, or listing claims. If a contractor disputes their grade, we review the underlying data — but the scoring formula applies equally to everyone.

How often are grades updated?

We refresh contractor data on a rolling basis. Major changes — new reviews, license updates, business closures — are reflected in the next monthly grading pass. After a rough Wisconsin winter, expect bigger shakeups in the spring.

Why isn't every gutter company in the Fox Valley listed?

We only list contractors with enough public data to score meaningfully. If a shop has no online presence, no reviews, and no stated credentials, there's nothing to grade — and nothing we'd comfortably recommend to a homeowner we don't know.

What if I think a grade is wrong?

Send us the specifics through our contact page. If we find an error in the underlying data, we'll correct it and rerun the score.

How It Works

01

Browse Services

Explore our gutter service categories

02

Compare Pros

Read reviews and compare local gutter pros

03

Get Estimates

Request free quotes from top-rated professionals

04

Hire with Confidence

Choose the best pro for your project

JK
ML
RS
50+

Protect your home with professional gutter services today.

Get A Free Estimate